Home > PublicationsEncyclopediaSmith v. Townsend (1893)

SMITH v. TOWNSEND (1893).

After the Land Run of April 22, 1889, into the Oklahoma District (Unassigned Lands), many land claims were challenged. By 1892, according to the register of the Oklahoma Land Office, an estimated five thousand land entries were being contested. Most of these were "sooner cases" involving persons who had entered the Oklahoma lands between March 2, 1889, and high noon of April 22, 1889.

Smith v. Townsend involved conflicting claims to part of the present city of Edmond. The contested tract was the Northeast Quarter of Section 34, Township 14 North, Range 3 West. In January 1889 Alexander B. Smith, a Santa Fe railroad worker, had pitched a tent at Edmond Station in the railroad right-of-way, lived there, and worked on the tracks until April 22. At the time appointed for the run, he had moved his tent out of the railroad right-of-way and claimed the entire quarter section. Around high noon on April 22, Eddie B. Townsend, who ranched on the Iowa reservation east of the Oklahoma District, joined the run. He arrived at Edmond Station at approximately 1:20 p.m. and entered a claim to the quarter section claimed by Smith.

Asserting that Smith was an illegal homesteader, a "sooner," Townsend asked the land register at Guthrie to cancel Smith's entry, because he had illegally occupied the land between March 2 and April 22, the period during which entry and occupation of the Oklahoma District had been prohibited. The local office upheld Smith's claim. Townsend appealed the decision to the commissioner of the U.S. General Land Office, who overturned the local decision. Townsend's claim was also upheld by the secretary of the interior in March 1891.

In a suit filed in Oklahoma County District Court, Smith asked the court to name Townsend a mere "trustee" for the land and to order the title conveyed to Smith. After appeals, in 1893 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against Smith. The decision stated that the federal government had not intended for railroad employees present in the Oklahoma District before the opening to have an advantage over persons who waited "on the line" outside the district. The decision noted that by legislative act and presidential proclamation Congress had thrown a wall around Oklahoma, and that "when the hour [noon on April 22, 1889] came, the wall was thrown down, and it was a race between all outside for the various tracts they might desire." Therefore, because he had not gone outside to wait on the line, but had stayed in the district, Smith had not been qualified to compete for a homestead.

Strictly interpreted, the decision could mean that any unauthorized person temporarily in the Unassigned Lands between March 2 and April 22 was disqualified. However, the courts generally applied the ruling only to disqualify those who had remained within the boundaries and by so doing had gained advantage in making a homestead or townsite entry. This set a precedent to be used in hundreds of townsite cases to come.

Dianna Everett

See also: KINGFISHER v. WOOD AND FOSSETT, LAND OPENINGS, LAND RUN OF 1889, SETTLEMENT PATTERNS, UNASSIGNED LANDS

Bibliography

Berlin B. Chapman, "The Legal Sooners of 1889 in Oklahoma," The Chronicles of Oklahoma 35 (Winter 1957–58).

Stan Hoig, The Oklahoma Land Rush of 1889 (Oklahoma City: Oklahoma Historical Society, 1984).

Copyright and Terms of Use

No part of this site may be construed as in the public domain.

Copyright to all articles and other content in the online and print Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History is held by the Oklahoma Historical Society. This includes individual articles (copyright to OHS by author assignment) and corporately (as a complete body of work), including web design, graphics, searching functions, and listing/browsing methods. Copyright to all of these materials is protected under United States and International law.

Users agree not to download, copy, modify, sell, lease, rent, reprint, or otherwise distribute these materials, or to link to these materials on another web site, without authorization of the Oklahoma Historical Society. Individual users must determine if their use of the Materials falls under United States copyright law's "Fair Use" guidelines and does not infringe on the proprietary rights of the Oklahoma Historical Society as the legal copyright holder of The Encyclopedia and part or in whole.

Photo credits: All photographs presented in the published and online versions of The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture are the property of the Oklahoma Historical Society and are held in the agency's Research Division Photograph Archives (unless otherwise stated).


Citation

The following (as per The Chicago Manual of Style, 16th edition) is the preferred citation for articles:
Dianna Everett, "Smith v. Townsend (1893)," The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture, www.okhistory.org (accessed November 19, 2017).

Links of Interest


About the Encyclopedia | Terms of Use | Using the Encyclopedia