A Very OK Podcast

Episode 63: “Historic Preservation and a Sense of Community”

November 17, 2026



Episode Transcript

(upbeat music playing)

Dr. Bob Blackburn: Welcome to another episode of A Very OK Podcast. I am your co-host, Bob Blackburn, here today, going solo. Trait Thompson is out of the office. He is so bogged down with duties on Route 66 100th anniversary this year and a variety of things that all come along in the fall. He is elsewhere today, so he said, just go ahead and Bob and get it done. So after 50-some episodes, here I am alone for the first time, but feel very comfortable because I am with one of my best friends since 1970. A lot of you weren’t born even then, but in 1970 I met Melvena Thurman, now Melvena Heisch, when we were both students at Southwestern Oklahoma State University, called Southwestern State College then, and she was a historian. We worked together ever since. Melvena, welcome to A Very OK Podcast.

Melvena Heisch: Thank you. It’s a pleasure to be here.

Blackburn: Well, like I said, Melvena, let me give you a little bit of an introduction, Melvena; you’ll probably blush because I love to brag about you. You’re one of my heroes. But Melvena, raised on a ranch in Roger Mills County, went to school out there. Her dad Melvin was a great friend of mine. Big rawbone rancher, farmer, could do a little bit of everything, and just kind of the backbone of America, in my opinion, just, you know, creating value out of the land. Well, Melvena was raised in that environment, went to Southwestern, got her college degree. I was out of college a year. She was behind me. But then when I started OSU the next year, she was enrolled in the master’s program. Again, we reconnected there. Then Melvena was, she finished her degree, did an internship at the Oklahoma Historical Society, and got a job in the Historic Preservation Office working with Howard Meredith, one of our joint mentors all those years. And then, Melvena would become deputy SHPO, state historic preservation officer, for many years, noted around the land, recipient of many national awards, state awards. Got a medal last year from the Kirkpatrick Foundation on Melvena and her impact on preservation in our history. Recognized across the country, still on some national panels dealing with historic preservation in the state. And she has such a memory of this program since it began. Melvena, congratulations on a great career as deputy SHPO.

Heisch: Thank you. I was very lucky to get to have that career with the Oklahoma Historical Society all those years.

Blackburn: Why don’t you start by talking about Howard Meredith and Howard hiring you, and then a little bit of what the State Historic Preservation does, why it was created, how it’s funded, and its mission.

Heisch: Okay. Well, as Bob said, I was doing my master’s program at Oklahoma State, and my committee chairman was Dr. LeRoy Fischer. Another connection for Bob and me, a professor there. And a part of my program was to complete an internship. I did most of the time here, with the Oklahoma Historical Society, and some with what’s known today as the Oklahoma Hall of Fame. But I came in August of ’75 to start my internship, and in November of that year, Howard Meredith assumed his position here as the one and only paid staff member of the State Historic Preservation Office. These offices were created under the National Historic Preservation Act, and the duties of that program had been scattered about at the Oklahoma Historical Society.

The State had not ever established a separate department, and the National Park Service oversees those programs and let the state know, the State of Oklahoma know, that it was time for them to expand what they were doing and to employ professional staff. And Howard was hired. He had a doctorate degree in history. And his wife Mary Ellen was from this area. And they moved back to raise their family, and he met me doing my internship. And we got well-acquainted, got to know him, and they gave him permission to hire a temporary secretary. And Dr. Fischer had advised me, they offer you a job, take it. Don’t worry what it is. Get in the door. And that’s what I did. And so I worked with Howard then, until he left the agency in the fall of ’79 to move on to other things. But he was so supportive and a wonderful person to work for and really enjoyed just getting to know him and starting to learn the National Historic Preservation Act program.

Blackburn: Well, as you said, we shared the experience of Southwestern and Mel Fiegel, and Terry Wilson, and Clarence Petrowsky, and some of those great teachers and professors, but we also shared LeRoy Fischer at OSU. But then I even consider us sharing Howard Meredith, because when I was a graduate student, this would have been the summer or the spring of ’77, I think it was. And one day, I happened to be enjoying a little beverage in a place on the strip in Stillwater. And Odie Faulk, who is our, he was head of my committee at the time, and Odie was a former Marine, didn’t drink, and he expected us to work 18 hours a day. That was just way Odie was. Well, I looked up, and he’s walking in the door, and he’s walking towards me. And I tell my friends, oh no, I’m in trouble. I’m here drinking a beer, and I should be studying. And Odie said, Blackburn, get to Oklahoma City tomorrow morning. Go see Howard Meredith. He’s got a project. I said, yes, sir. I didn’t know what it was, but I went down, and Howard and you explained it to me.

Local Public Works “Act Two” and the Carter administration, they expected a lot of money going out for projects that needed federal action, and it would be reviewed in your office. So, you two hired me to do that survey that year, and that was my entry into the Oklahoma Historical Society. Like your story, take any job. LeRoy was a smart man. I started working here. A lot of people thought I was working here before I ever had a job, because I was doing so much consulting, making a little extra money and all of that. But speaking of that Local Public Works, that’s a nice segue into what does the Preservation Office do? If you say, and I know there are a couple of elements to the program, but there’s a common binding there.

Heisch: The National Historic Preservation Act was passed in 1966. We just celebrated its 60th anniversary last month. President Johnson signed it into law on October 15, 1966, and the main driving force for its passage was the concern about the loss of so many historic resources under federal construction projects that were going on at the time. It was the heyday of Urban Renewal Authority. There was a lot of highway construction and other things using federal funds, and there was nothing in place to require the federal government to consider what they might be destroying in a community. I mean, it was the federal government charged, providing money. People were looking for redevelopment in their communities, improved highways, and they were just ready to go. And it was suddenly realized how much was just being lost with just no thought, and so that was sort of the driving force for it. They commissioned a blue ribbon panel that studied the loss of historic fabric and its importance to our country and was issued under the study titled A Heritage So Rich. And you can still get a copy of that today, but the National Historic Preservation Act then established the National Register of Historic Places, and it created authorization for the National Park Service to oversee all of the programs under it, including the National Register, the survey program, educational and outreach activities, actual restoration grant programs, and for there to be an SHPO, State Historic Preservation Officer, in every state. And the crux then of the act, and it’s all tied together. All of these programs are linked, in some way or another.

And the part of the act known as Section 106 provided that federal agencies were legally and financially responsible for considering the impact of their construction activities on properties, archaeological or historic properties, that were listed on, or eligible for, the National Register, and that final “eligible for” will become very critical as time passes. Because just because a building had never been studied before and was in the path of a highway or whatever the construction was, didn’t mean it might not have significance and need to be given consideration. So, as the time passed, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, which is an independent federal agency authorized under the act, then established the regulations and the guidelines and worked with the SHPOs and with federal agencies to make sure they were complying with that segment of the law. And the SHPOs became the critical and foundational part of the compliance with the advisory council’s regulations. We were there to assist federal agencies, or those receiving federal funds, or a federal permit, to make sure that everybody was in compliance, not to direct them to either do or not do the project, but to guide them through the process to make sure that there was consideration given, and that if there was to be an effect on a building or archaeological site or historic district, was it going to be adverse? And if so, could we redesign the project to avoid that or minimize it? And if none of that was possible, which sometimes it was not, or many times it’s not, you would develop a plan for how to mitigate that adverse effect. And in instances, you could simply require special documentation of the resource to be lost. Or perhaps it was something that could be moved to a new location.

There was no limit on the creativity and the cooperative efforts between the federal agencies and the SHPO, and sometimes the advisory council when they had to come in and help us with the complicated project.

Blackburn: And Melvena, that brings up, I was state historic preservation officer for 23 years, with Melvena’s assistance. Basically, I did everything Melvena told me to do, but I was the official signator. Of course, I granted a lot of that to Melvena, her authority. But one thing that I found over the years, misconceptions about the National Register. One, it’s going to keep me from controlling my own property. It never had any local implications. People confuse city historic preservation districts, where there are some limitations of what you can do with your own property, which is a zoning issue, and then the National Register that has nothing about restricting.

And then, secondly, is that an agency could not do it. There were means for them to go ahead with a critical project. And you and I had to deal with that a lot with bridges especially, that were unsafe. And we were never going to argue that historic fabric had to be saved. Well it’s going to kill people. That’s just common sense. So you would help negotiate with ODOT or whatever agency if it was a safety issue, something that threatened quality of life. You know, we’d sit and talk. So it was not a prohibition. It was a process itself to come to the best conclusions is really what it was.

Heisch: That’s right. And you hear a lot about how the review processes like Section 106 hold up permitting or funding construction projects for years and that may happen in some instances, but it’s extremely rare. And of the tens of thousands, literally tens of thousands of federal undertakings, that went through the office during my time, and I picked up on this statistic from other states as well, it’s pretty consistent that about less than 2% of all the projects are ultimately found to have an adverse effect that has to be dealt with. Most of them go very quickly. The review times on average through the SHPO here, from the time the request hits your desk until the letter is out the door, here’s about 14 days or less, when you’re given 30. So it moves very efficiently.

And I was always very lucky as the deputy SHPO to have a staff that was really dedicated to what they do, worked really hard to be helpful to the agencies, and we had many very good cooperative relationships and very professional relationships with people at ODOT, at the Department of Commerce, at, you know, the Wildlife Department or the Department of Ag, or wherever the federal dollars were flowing into the state. And so it was a really a good working environment for the most part. Now, we didn’t always agree, and there were sometimes some difficult projects to work through. But we always got to the other end and met the mission of the agency and, to the maximum extent the law allows, to protect the historic resources we were able to save.

Blackburn: Yeah, well anybody who cares about sense of place in Oklahoma or the country, these things, these buildings, these places, the archaeology that binds us together into our shared community, are extremely important. And so having this program is essential, and Congress right now is considering weakening some of these things. So I am going to just go out on a limb and say, if you have a chance to call your congressman, let them know that the Historic Preservation Act has saved thousands of buildings, has, and we’ll get into other aspects of it here and what it’s done for our community since it passed in the ’60s. But as many of you viewers know, if you’re a regular listener, is that we tried to tie all of our themes this year, to Route 66, and we can do it with this particular theme. So I’m going to ask Melvena here in a minute about that.

But as I normally do, Trait usually gives me a chance to connect the dots of history and set the stage. And of course, in our lives, this stage of history is always turning. Conditions are always changing, challenges are coming up, opportunities are there, and our progress as a state and a nation is how well we deal with the challenges, how well we seize the opportunities and then make a difference, and invest, and go forward, and pull the community together rather than separate it. Well, Route 66 is one of those unifying projects. In my mind, it really starts in 1919, when Congress expands the federal highway grant program coming out of World War I. The military especially, but Congress in general, recognized that we had no adequate interstate highway system. There was no way to get from here to there efficiently on these old dirt roads that followed section lines, largely unpaved, a lot of times, dirt or sand. Very few bridges. Some states, more populous, more tax base had done some, but it was not consistent. And Dwight D. Eisenhower, I think he was a lieutenant at the time after the war, was on a convoy trying to get from the East Coast to the West Coast, and it took something like 47 days. That’s not going to be exact, but it’s about that long to get from coast to coast. Congress says we’ve got to do something about it. So they come up with a program to offer grants-in-aid to the states, asking the states to match the money and asking the states to invest it wisely, not just the good ol’ boy county commissioners have it all, but there has to be a professional engineer. There has to be a staff that goes out and surveys, pick the best routes, and a commission that involves the state authority. Well, Oklahoma typically, dragged its feet just as it did with Historic Preservation. Going from, what was that Melvena, ’66 when the law passed to ’70 something when they finally had a professional staff. So we were dragging their feet, typically, and happened then.

Well, nothing happens in 1920, ’21, even ’22. And the state has no pool of money to go after these block grants to build highways on this interstate system. Well, finally, we get a new governor. Martin Trapp, who had been lieutenant governor, becomes full-time governor eight months after Jack Walton has been inaugurated and then impeached. He becomes governor, and he makes good roads his primary campaign issue. He says, we have got to enter the 20th century with better roads. Cars are coming, more cars all the time. Already Henry Ford had built an assembly plant for Model Ts in Oklahoma City on West Main. The building is still there today, the Fordson Hotel. But you know, the cost coming down of automobiles $300, $400, and more people driving, more people could afford it. And there was a demand for roads. Well, Trapp put together the federal grants. The public’s demand for better roads pushed up, pushed really against the county commissioners, who were the most powerful state agents at the time. County commissioners had 100% control over roads in the county.

Well, you can imagine where the paved roads went. They were largely confined to Oklahoma County, Tulsa County, Comanche County, may have been Garfield County, but where there was a lot of tax revenue is that they would build, they would pave highways. But that stopped at the county line. So the county commissioners did not want to give up that authority, and they could not come up with the money to get those federal grants. So the legislature passes a bill creating what we now call the Oklahoma Department of Transportation. At the time, it’s called the Highway Commission, but it’s the same thing, operating under the same basic rules. And part of that legislation was putting together a professional staff that would be part of the Highway Commission. And for the first time, a tax other than property tax, and the new tax was a 2.5-cent tax on gasoline. And we have refineries all over Oklahoma. Cushing, of course, would have been a center of it after the Cushing oil strike in 1912. There would have been refineries in Enid, and Ponca City, and Bartlesville. Oklahoma City had several refineries. And so that was fairly common. So let’s tax that money when it gets from the refinery to the retailer, the gas station. And then that will create a pool.

Well, part of that pool of money went to the county commissioners for roads that are farm-to-market, largely. And then the bulk of it would go to this new state agency, giving them the authority to use that money to get the federal grants and to do these big projects in the 1920s. Well, fortunately for us, one of the county commissioners who believed in that system, who was a national figure by this time, was Cyrus Avery, Tulsa County commissioner, had originally moved Oklahoma City after the land run, then on to Vinita and then on to Tulsa, where he digs in, becomes county commissioner, farmer, an advocate for good water supply. Kind of those community leaders every community has to have, and he is very involved with the highway naming system. Pike’s Highway, it would have been a variety of these names that were given to these highways that would go from point A, like one would go from Hot Springs, Arkansas, to Colorado Springs, Colorado, and they had a name for it. Well, there were a bunch of those. He was involved with that group, becomes a national figure at this very time. And Martin Trapp says Cyrus, become my chairman of my highway commission. We’re going to get this thing done together. He becomes chairman. He’s growing with national status. And he’s there in 1926 when the Bureau of Roads is trying to come up with a numbering system. What numbers do we give to these highways? Highways going east and west, north and south, a numbering system that would work. So you don’t have the same number on two highways that are interstate, and he is there and uses his influence to say, we are going to build one of these interstate highways that goes from Chicago to Los Angeles. It’s going to come through my hometown, Tulsa, Oklahoma, which meant it also came through Oklahoma City and then skirted the Rocky Mountains on the south. It’s authorized in 1926. Thus, this year, the centennial celebration.

Now, it would take us in Oklahoma until 1937 to finish paving all of that, and the paving was done largely with a lot of DOT/WPA work, federal grants again, for labor, state coming up with materials, but it was finally paved in 1937. Well, what happened is that the highway itself would then become historic over the years, especially after it was decommissioned with the interstate system, what, in the ’80s, Melvena?

Heisch: ’85.

Blackburn: And then too, all of the places along the route that would become important iconic landmarks, hotels, amusement parks, art, bridges, the whole variety of things that pop up around this cultural phenomenon of building Route 66 from east to west. And then, of course, we get Disney World, we get tourists after World War II and their cars going west to see the Painted Desert, the Grand Canyon, and Hoover Dam, and all these things that we think of as touring in the West and the tourism explodes.

Well, fast-forward to the 1980s, and a lot of those resources are being threatened. And knowing that this celebration was coming in ’26, this is 20 years ago. Melvena Heisch, sitting across from me right now, brilliant young lady who used to set the curve in our history exam at Southwestern, to my regret, because I was then coming in number two on tests. But Melvena said, we need to get ahead of this, and let’s do a survey of all of those culturally important places along Route 66, both the roadbed, the bridges, the infrastructure, but also those sites along the route. Melveina, talk about starting this survey and the process of saying, yeah, this is how we’re going to spend some of our federal money this year, then who did you find to do the survey and kind of what were the results?

Heisch: Okay. Well, as I mentioned earlier, survey of archaeological and historical resources is a fundamental part of the National Historic Preservation Act. And I think that when it was first passed, there was this idea that states would use their federal monies from the Historic Preservation Fund to get the surveys done quickly, and then we would move on to other things about how to how to preserve them. But it was very, very quickly realized that the time and money that were going to be necessary to get this done, it wasn’t going to happen fast. And it’s a big country, and the states out here in the west have huge square mileages to address, and many towns and cities, and it was just not going to be feasible to get it done quickly. And so the Park Service started trying to incentivize speeding it up some in the early ’80s by adjusting, through the law, the matching ratio for those federal funds. And for your survey program, you could do a 70/30 match instead of the 50/50 match that was set up originally. So that meant that 70% of our survey efforts could be paid for with that federal grant to the state. Those grant amounts are apportioned to each state on the basis of the area of your state and your population, and sometimes other factors are added in there so that you distribute the money. You don’t just go tell Congress that our state needs $2 million. You don’t do that. They tell you how much you’re going to receive, and then you budget it, and you’re required to cover a professional staff, operating expenses, as well as carry out your survey work. So there was just never going to be adequate money or staff to do this on our own out of the SHPO.

So Howard Meredith had initiated the process, and I expanded on it, to develop partnerships with both Oklahoma State University and with the University of Oklahoma. At OU, we partnered with the Oklahoma Archeological Survey down there to deal with the prehistoric archaeological resources, and that’s a topic for another episode. But the relationship we created at OSU was with their history department and also with their geography department. And professors that would be interested in the topics that we were looking at, would put together a team of graduate students, and the university was providing the match that we needed through those, the payment to those students and part of the professor’s salary and their travel costs and things like that. So they were our financial partner as well as our partner for just doing the work. And we would have never been able to utilize the federal funds coming to us if it were not for that. And in the early ’80s, as we’re looking at expanding our survey, and some surveys are done on the basis of geography, such as surveying Tulsa, or Oklahoma City, or Weatherford, or Miami, wherever you are. You can do a city. You can do a watershed. You might look at a county. And we had started by just kind of a canvas of the state doing National Register nominations with the Department of History, but that was only getting us isolated examples in various communities. You would hit the well known sites, people that had already put up historic markers or whatever. They were easy to find, to recognize. I mean, everybody knows the State Capitol is a historic building, and it would be one that we would get the nomination done for. But in the ’80s, the concept of thematic surveys became very popular, and we really did a lot of work statewide under those themes.

We began the survey of WPA-built resources in Oklahoma. That took from ’84 to ’87, three years of agreements. But during that time, we were looking at other themes, and it was very much in the news, and people were talking about the decommissioning of Route 66 was coming in ’85, and there was a lot of concern. It was so popular through movies and the TV series and songs, and people just knew about it. You knew it was there and I think maybe taken for granted that we just thought these places will always be there. And then when they realized what decommissioning was going to mean, especially in the smaller communities, there’s a lot of concern.

So during our preparation for that year’s work program, I had learned through our public commenting that OSU had a professor there who had a real interest in the road and was a car guy, and that was Dr. Joseph Stout. And they had also employed Dr. Mary Anne Anders to come in and lead their survey efforts they were doing for us. So, Joe and Mary Ann became the lead investigators on our first Route 66 survey. And all we could do that year, due to limitations of money and time, was to look at the 1926 alignment of the road. Of course, it’s going to change alignments many times through the years, and we would address all of that in later years. But that initial survey recorded things for all the way from the length of the road in Oklahoma, and a few of them that you would pick up on today, the Rock Creek Bridge over in Sapulpa, the Rock Cafe, 11th Street Bridge in Tulsa, just all kinds of properties on the east side. And then as we moved out west, we picked up one of my, the Casa Grande Hotel in Elk City is a personal favorite, as is the West Wind Motel in Erick. There were just all kinds of things all along that original alignment, and each of those properties were photographed, and location was documented on maps. Physical descriptions were written and a brief historical narratives on each one. And it has to be very brief in a survey. There’s not time, and it’s not the purpose of a survey like that to get the complete history of every property. But we recorded dozens and dozens of things, and I think we were surprised at how much was still out there and connected to the road. Diners, service stations. We had a Phillips 66 Station in Chandler The Victory over in Tulsa, the Jackson Conoco station in El Reno. They’re just all up and down the highway. There’s hardly a town we went through that we didn’t record a historic filling station, and you would learn how the styles of those service stations had changed through time, and they would look very different in those early years compared to what the more modern ones that were being built into the ’60s and ’70s in a modern architecture style. So it was great fun. It generated a lot of enthusiasm, and it provided the base for a lot of other preservation activities to occur over the next three or four decades as we approach the centennial, and you cannot have a successful historic preservation program at the local, state, or national level if you don’t know what you have, what your resources are.

And so that’s where you always begin is with the survey. And then you build on that through special designations like the National Register or some of the other programs that we’ll talk about later. And it also, the survey data is all maintained by the SHPO. And in early days, it was paper files. That’s all there was. And of course, today they have a very sophisticated digital system for maintaining all of that. And it’s searchable, and it’s much, much more efficient, for our main users of that data are the federal agencies or the state or local governments using money and federal money to do their construction projects. And it’s important to them to know if their project area includes any potentially historic properties. So that survey data helps save other agencies a lot of time and resources if the SHPO has already covered that area through one of their surveys. And Route 66 is certainly a very good example of how we had so much information available, how it really helped ODOT on a lot of their plans.

Blackburn: Well, and in a lot of ways, Melvena, it is the bedrock for really using those resources for economic development, cultural tourism. Michael Wallis would write his book in 1990. Jim Ross would do all of his extensive work over the years, one of our heroes, and then our Route 66 Museum was opened in 1995. You see all that data, so it’s very important. Well, before we get on to other topics here, talking about Route 66 and other historic buildings, let’s take a short break for this message.

Announcer: Great coaches do more than win games. They inspire athletes, build character, and shape communities. Opening December 7 at the Oklahoma History Center Museum, More Than a Game: Coaches of Oklahoma celebrates the coaches who have made a lasting impact on Oklahoma sports history, from youth leagues all the way to the Olympics. Through photographs, artifacts, and personal stories, discover how their influence reaches far beyond the scoreboard. Visit the Oklahoma History Center Museum in Oklahoma City and experience More Than a Game: Coaches of Oklahoma, opening December 7.

Blackburn: Well, welcome back to A Very OK Podcast. Here today, Bob Blackburn talking with Melvena Heisch, longtime friend. In fact, Melvena, if ’70 was actually the year, I’m know that’s when I met because that was your freshman year, my sophomore year at Southwestern. We’ve been friends for 56 years. You’re better at math than I am! I know that for sure. But 56 years, long time. And you and Debbie, my wife, were extremely close. Probably talked every day the last few years of her life. And I always appreciated that, and she treasured that friendship. But we’ve been talking about Route 66 and the survey.

Well, Melvena, let’s talk about a couple of the preservation projects of some of those properties along the route. And both of us have a soft spot in our hearts for the Round Barn in Arcadia. One, I grew up in Edmond, and Tootie and Charlie Teuscher were good friends, and Tootie Teuscher was from the family that had the Tuton’s Drugstore in Arcadia, and she owned a quarter section of land where I used to quail hunt as a teenager. But the Round Barn was always important to all of us traveling Route 66. We knew about its importance, and then a windstorm knocked it down. So at that point, it was not going to be a federal undertaking. But we understood the importance of the Round Barn as a very unique barn on Route 66 that millions of travelers had seen. It was a landmark. Almost everyone would have mentioned that. And tell us about Luke Robison.

Heisch: Luke Robison was one of those rare individuals that comes along. Every nonprofit needs a Luke out there, and he loved that barn. He was so dedicated to it. And as Bob said, the storm had caused, it was near collapse, and the locals there had propped up one side of it with big poles. It was all that was holding it up. And the barn’s roof, the best way I can describe that is it looks like a basket turned upside down. It is an amazing structure. And it had caved in on one side, and it was Luke and some of his volunteers that went up and figured out how to fix that roof and reconstruct, and it was amazing. It was just amazing. There were people who just flat giving up on it, thought it was just lost, and we just had to sit and watch it. But Luke was able to lead the effort and to put it back the way it should have been. A restoration, not just a repair job. They restored that barn and the barn itself was on the National Register before we did the Route 66 survey, but there were so many of the things like the barn along the road that were the landmarks that the tourists came to love and to photograph. And Luke would help raise money there. He had a book that he wrote called Made Out of Mud, and it was a history of brick manufacturers in Oklahoma. And he made little miniature bricks himself, and I believe they read Arcadia. I still have one.

Blackburn: I have one as well.

Heisch: He gave me, and they sold those little bricks to help raise money for that project, just so, so dedicated to that barn. And it’s still there today. It has benefited in subsequent phases of its maintenance and restoration from some of the federal grants from the National Park Service’s Route 66 program. So it’s just interwoven into the story of the road, and there’s nobody that’s toured, driven down the highway that won’t have seen it, and a whole lot of them have stopped just to visit.

Blackburn: And Luke, to me, was so unique because a lot of people who have that kind of passion will raise the money and hire someone to do it. Luke had a construction background. He was on site, and I’ll never forget I went out to tour one day. He had scaffolding built in the middle of the barn, going all the way. Luke himself was tying the rafters together, and that was probably 80 to 90 feet above the floor. And I would guess, you know, I, feel like I’m still a young man at 75, and he probably was a young man of 65 or something, but he was still up there hanging those rafters. And, you know, I think we had estimated the renovation, if it had to go out for bid, it would have been a million or plus was our estimate, as I recall. And he did it for much less and then just pull it off.

Heisch: And so much, it had to be curved. The members, a lot of it had to be curved. And he took some of that material, as I recall, and soaked it in the creek so they could bend it and shape it.

Blackburn: And he had some of the old rafters as a template that he could reproduce. And because of that project, Aubrey McClendon, probably who changed philanthropy in Oklahoma more than anybody since E. W. Marland did in the 1920s. Aubrey was buying land along Deep Fork River to put in his tree farms. He had a real interest in tree farms and landscaping and beautification efforts, and he owned some land not far from the Round Barn, and he hired a innovative young architect we had used to design the Route 66 Museum. Rand Elliott, he hired Rand to develop a brand new service station/cafe/sale shop with a huge pop collection, and Rand did this amazing cantilevered front of it. It doesn’t look like it could stand up, but Rand figured out, his engineers figured out how to do it. But it’s become a landmark. So we have new landmarks going along with old landmarks, making this driving experience still valuable today. So, you know, Aubrey and Luke, people like that make history happen. Melvena, any other projects along the route and the restoration that kind of come to mind?

Heisch: Oh, goodness.

Blackburn: Well, how about the round dome?

Heisch: The Gold Dome. Yeah, that’s a good one. Again, another landmark that was built. The Gold Dome as we refer to it here, as with Citizens State Bank is what it was built for, and it’s a geodesic dome. And if anyone who’s been in Oklahoma City near Northwest 23rd and Classen and has been right by it. Fact is we direct a lot of people how to find our house, , you know, you find the dome, and that’s how you get there. But it became quickly something. Everybody wanted to see it because it was so like space-age kind of looking thing. And there were postcards of that taken, you know, people had those. Friends of mine were getting those postcards when they came over here to the State Fair or whatever. They were coming up with them and bringing them home. And it just became like the Round Barn, a place to stop and take a photograph and look around. But through time, the banking change, they didn’t need that kind of space, and it changed hands a couple of times. And the bank moved out, and the property was put up for sale around 2003, 2004, and a buyer came forward who planned to tear it down and build a pharmacy, a drugstore, chain drugstore on that. And that set off a huge uproar. Protests were held weekly out there for a year. And finally it all resolved. A buyer was found who wouldn’t tear it down and renovated the building. And so it that saved it for a while.

Sadly, it’s empty again, and it’s had a couple of owners since. But recently it was on a sheriff’s auction, and it’s unclear yet what the plans are by the new owner. But they did find a buyer. So we still promote it as one of the major landmarks on the road, and we’re still hopeful that there will be a real preservation project occur there. It’s just an important corner in Oklahoma City where Route 66 passes there along the Uptown 23rd District and the Tower Theatre, with its great neon sign that everyone recognizes. So it’s an important part of the Route 66 legacy. I got to interview Bob Roloff, who is the architect on that project, before he passed away, and he gave us some sketches for our collections. But that’s a good segue, too, to another topic I want to bring up, Melvena. You know, we talked about historic preservation created to really create a process that would help federal agencies accomplish their mission without damaging historic resources. But we’ve found ways to get the private sector involved in preservation. We can say what’s important. We can recommend it. Sometimes the population recognizes it before we do. The Gold Dome is the one that surprised me with the outturn of support for there. And of course, Cliff Hudson, John Yoeckel, raised private money to file lawsuits. And, you know, people like that will get involved. But that gets us into tax credits, is that the federal government, off and on since the ’70s, has had a tax credit. If a private investor will acquire a historic building, and if they do things according to the Secretary of Interior Standards in the right way, they may be eligible for a tax credit. It’s been 10%. Feds raised it to 20, ultimately.

Well, in Oklahoma, Melvena and I both are personally involved in this because my wife, Debbie Blackburn, was in the legislature and loved historic buildings. She was a historian as well and went to Melvena, says Melvena. What can we do to enhance? And Melvena said, if we had a state tax credit that would match the federal. And so Debbie and Melvena hammered out the details of a tax credit, and lo and behold, it passed the legislature. A 20% state matching the federal, so 40%. And that was encouraging the private sector to invest. It’s a program that has been a runaway success. Both parties support it. Little towns, big cities, support it. It’s had an impact across the state. Hundreds of projects created thousands of jobs. There have been economic impact reports done on what it’s meant for our economy. Almost any other government program has paled compared to the impact of this preservation project. Melvena, let’s talk about, unless you want to add anything about creating the bill when you and Debbie did it, you kept it very simple where it is not another process. If someone got the federal credit, you got the state, and then your office would administer that. But let’s talk about two projects: one Oklahoma City, one and Tulsa, the Skirvin Hotel in Oklahoma City and the Mayo Hotel in Tulsa.

Heisch: The Skirvin Hotel, for those not familiar so much with Oklahoma City, especially downtown, is our landmark, our historic landmark hotel. And it had fallen on very hard times, was closed, a new developer took over in the late ’70s, early ’80s and tried to, did a kind of cosmetic approach to rehabilitation, but that didn’t last very long. And by 1989, it was standing vacant. It shut down, and it just sat there. A 13-to-14-story hotel in the middle of downtown, sitting there and deteriorating. And there was starting to be discussion about what do we do with this? Maybe it needs to come down. I walked through that building in the early ’90s with a representative of the Urban Renewal Authority, when there was no, the only power in the building was some emergency generator that had a light on in the stairwells, and we poked around the guest rooms in that hotel with flashlights. It was just a terrible situation. And I could see how somebody who didn’t love old buildings was just going to.

Blackburn: You know, the pigeon poop.

Heisch: The pigeon poop all over the floor up in the Venetian room. We went down into the ballroom where they had already started to clear out the furniture. People were trying to get rid of the stuff. I mean, they just walked off and left it when the last guest checked out on the last night. But they had stacked mattresses, almost floor to ceiling in the ballroom. I’ve never seen anything like that. I don’t know how they got them out of there. Some of the rooms that still had furniture in them, one room, the dirty bath towels had been left looped over the back of chairs, and it was just a horrible, horrible situation. And the person walking with me said, Melvena, what are we going to do with this? He said, what could we do with it? And I said, how about turning it back into a hotel? And he said, you’re kidding. He said, you’d have to charge $80 a night for the rooms in here. And he said, there’s never going to be anybody pay $80 a night to stay in downtown Oklahoma City. That’s what he said. And so time passes, and people begin to look at it with more favorable eyes. The tax credits come into play, and you’ve got the federal credit, and then that the state credit, kind of interestingly, the state credit already existed, if you were a historic hotel, that Debbie and I just built on that, is what we did. But they hadn’t really found anybody to step up. And then we had some very inspired leadership, I think, with the City of Oklahoma City.

Blackburn: Kirk Humphreys. I was on that committee. Kirk appointed me to it.

Heisch: Aand they took that seriously, and they were going to find a developer, and they did a competitive process to find the right developer to do it, and were selected The Skirvin Partners LLC, would be ultimately who did it, and we worked closely with them on their rehab plans. And it was one of those projects that make you very nervous because this is huge. And if it doesn’t succeed, if historic preservation appears to be in the way in some people’s eyes, then that’s bad for the future. But it went so very, very smoothly. The architects that we worked with, the developer himself, they were just very good partners. That’s the way the process is supposed to work. And Catherine Montgomery was the architect on my staff at the time. She’s now deceased, and she had a real passion for these projects, and she knew her stuff and was able to work so well with their design team. And they initially thought they would have to just basically gut the building and put in a whole new cookie-cutter format of rooms. But Catherine showed them that, no, that wasn’t going to be necessary. With a few modifications, you can make these the original room configurations and hallways still be there and retain a huge amount of the integrity of that building. And they were able to do that.

Blackburn: And today when you walk into the Skirvin, you really feel like you’re walking into, it’s not exactly like the 1909 lobby, back when that last development company that had it, they hired me to do a little history of the Skirvin. They were trying to promote it back during the deep gas boom, before Penn Square collapsed and natural gas industry collapsed. And I wrote a 20-page essay. So I became an advocate for it. And I’ll never forget, I was doing another book and meeting with one of the leading urban leaders in Oklahoma City, the man with most of the money, most of the decisions, power of the pen. And he asked me one day, he said, Dr. Blackburn, what do you think of the Skirvin Hotel? And I said, sir, it’s the kind of person you don’t want to take. I said, well, what do you think, sir? He’s like, ought to tear it down. The land is worth more valuable than the buildings. I said, sir, I’m going to have to respectfully disagree with you. That is one of those buildings that connects the fabric of Oklahoma City. Its brick exterior, there are no other major brick buildings downtown. I said it was a hotel where people had proms, and parties, and weddings, and events, and engagements. And I said, it’s part of our common memory in this state, and we need it. And because of those Skirvin partners, and I’m very, I’m proud of my little bit of involvement. Not much. Kirk Humphreys deserves a lot of credit and the city, Cathy O’Connor, people like that stay. Chuck Wiggin and the state found out other grants and ways to save money, and they put together a budget. And that hotel is still a landmark in downtown Oklahoma City today.

Heisch: I think the City had some federal loans, and it was also a Section 106 review case for us, which brought two programs together, and the financial obligations to the city were paid off much more quickly than the city had purchased. It was CDBG money. That’s what it was. And the loans, the funding was paid off more quickly than expected. They had a higher occupancy rate than they had ever imagined. The visiting NBA teams playing the Thunder started staying there. That’s where they were booking their rooms. And it’s just an amazing project to develop. The owners of it, a part of the deal, part of the deal for the city’s assistance, they granted a façade easement on that building that runs in perpetuity. So it will be protected. So just a very good story, worked so well, many programs come together. And the city government, state government, federal, all working very well together with that private sector.

Blackburn: But it starts with historic preservation, knowing what’s important, why it’s important, and putting together the two to do something about it. Well, of course, in Tulsa we have another major hotel that was close to being torn down. It had already been gutted. And the Mayo Hotel, the Mayo family, extremely important in Tulsa history. It was in the heart of downtown Tulsa. It would have been the place that presidents would have stayed. So Eisenhower probably stayed there. Truman probably stayed there. You know, that’s the kind of building it was. Beautiful architecture, and it had already been cleared. People were using it as a parking garage, literally, until Bill Snyder comes along. Kind of give you an overview of that project, Melvena, and how that comes together.

Heisch: Yeah, our office had been asked to look at the project a couple of times over the years, and I don’t recall how long it had been vacant, but it sat there a long time. And they had one developer that we were very hopeful about sometime in the early ’80s, and when my staff was up there to walk through the building with them. John Hill is who went, and the developers, architects were telling him how horrible all the windows were, and they were going to replace them all, which would have pretty much assured they were not going to get the tax credit because of what they had planned. And John talked to them about that and explained what they could do to refurbish them. And after they put the pencils to paper, discovered how much money that was going to save them in the long run. So they agreed to leave the windows and started work on demolition that has to be done inside, sheetrock. I mean, it was terrible. I mean, it had a bunch of stuff had to be pulled out. All that was pretty much left were the stud walls by the time. And something happened to the financing for that developer, and he pulled out. And so it would sit there until the Snyders. I don’t believe there ever was a really serious effort until they came in and just turned it into a really first-class place to stay, and I believe it was the conference hotel for the Statewide Preservation Conference in 2018 after I had retired. We had them set up to go back to Tulsa, and that hotel was hosted there. So just really, it’s in a position in downtown Tulsa, like the Skirvin is in Oklahoma City, and you just have to have your landmark hotel to be a shining star for your city.

Blackburn: It brings people to the downtown. It employs people downtown. It really is necessary for a community to really work. Well, Melvena, we’re about out of time. But if people want to find out more about the buildings in their own town. So if you’re in El Reno, what buildings in El Reno are on the National Register? How do they get to that information?

Heisch: Oh, it’s very easy to do with internet today and websites. This is so much easier. And another day, I would have said just call the SHPO, and they’ll mail you the hard copy of our National Register handbook. And it’s organized by county and by city, and it’ll have a supplement tucked inside. And they may still have an old supply of those, but the easiest way is just to go to the Oklahoma Historical Society’s website and look at your menu and choose State Historic Preservation Office, and you will find it right there under their programs, county by county, city by city. It’s a searchable database, and you can pull up Canadian County in El Reno and just see everything right there. It’ll give you the name of the property, the address, and the date it was listed in the National Register. And it gives you the codes to the National Register criteria so you know why it’s important. Is it important for its historical significance to the community? Does it also have architectural significance? Was it associated with an important person? So it’s all right there. They keep it up to date, and I haven’t checked the number lately, but I’m sure it’s well over 1,400 buildings, structures, sites, districts, and objects all across the state. Every county has got something listed. Most have multiple listings. And if your city doesn’t have a listing, and you know of a building where you think it might qualify, right there will give you an instruction, very simple, on how to find out from the SHPO if they think it’s eligible. And maybe you’ve got a business in that building that where you might be able to use those tax credits to help you with your refurbishment.

Blackburn: Try it, and that’s okhistory.org is the website to go and then get preservation. But there are also listings of the National Registers that are copies of the National Register nomination forms that have the history, the significance, the architectural description, and for people who like to poke around in little towns of Oklahoma, they have a little weekend trip. To me, it pays off to pull those up to read about these buildings. It’s like having a historic marker in front of the building. You’ve got it right there on the internet, so if you have a tablet, you can pull it up as you’re standing in front of it, reading about it. It’s the part of collecting, the Historical Society. I don’t know if we came up with originally or where it came from, but we used it forever. But our mission is to collect, preserve, and share, and the collections of the Historic Preservation Office are fundamental to understanding a lot of our local history. So much has been accumulated now, after 50-some years of doing the surveys, nominations, working on projects, it’s a heck of a resource for us to really appreciate our own history. Melvena, thank you so much for joining me today and sharing with our listeners all your experience and your leadership. And I have always admired you and appreciate what you’ve done for the state and the Oklahoma Historical Society. And you’re still an active player with some national groups and hope things keep going well for you.

Heisch: Thank you very much. It’s been a pleasure, and really enjoyed the conversation.

Blackburn: For a girl from Radon, Oklahoma, you’ve done well. All right. Thank you. Well, everyone, thank you again for listening to another episode of A Very OK Podcast.

(upbeat music playing)

Trait Thompson: You’ve been listening to A Very OK Podcast, hosted by Trait Thompson and Dr. Bob Blackburn. The podcast is produced by the Oklahoma Historical Society. Visit us at okhistory.org, and find us on social media by searching for @okhistory. I encourage you to purchase a membership to OHS to help us continue our mission to collect, preserve, and share Oklahoma’s unique and fascinating history.

(upbeat music playing)




Listen to A Very OK Podcast on these platforms

 Apple Podcasts     Spotify      Amazon Music      YouTube